When Agatha turned thirteen a few weeks ago, she had a sleep-over birthday party. It was an understated affair, as they usually are by that age, with just two other girls: a private and elegant candle-lit dinner in the dining room while the seven other members of our family cowered and ate quietly in the kitchen. I was allowed to take one photograph, discretely, and lead the girls in song while bringing out the cake.
After cheesecake and chocolate sauce and ice cream and cherry sauce and presents, they fled cackling to Agatha's bedroom, emerging every few hours to gather snacks. It was understood that during these kitchen forays the rest of us were to be elsewhere, anywhere. Other than the incessant giggles and the occasional sounds of stomping, (dancing?) and moving around of furniture, they didn't make much noise and we were, as sleepover hosts, resigned to letting the noise be what it would be. I think the girls had a good time, and we seven leftover Sullivans did our job handily: the job of being inconspicuous.
It just so happens that the last birthday party sleep-over I remember attending was also a thirteenth birthday. The birthday girl was someone fairly new to our school -- so new that the invitees, I'm embarrassed to say, all convened privately in small groups to discuss whether or not we'd be attending. My school had a caste system that rivaled that of India's during the British occupation, and being new and having not yet gotten the lay of the land, Katy Cooper had invited across caste lines. In fact, her own caste was yet to be determined. (It was known that she had money, but it was rumored to be new money.)
I was a shy child which automatically placed me slightly below whatever my caste might be financially, but I was also one of the small group of children who lived within the city limits, in the lower East Side near UW--Milwaukee. I was a PK, a Professor's Kid, and for some reason the children of professors were allowed some latitude even if their parents didn't own real estate on Sanibel Island.
We all decided to go.
There were at least twelve of us invited, and we arrived in carpools. Since this was a private school, we didn't all live in the same district or even the same county.
The first thing we noticed is that Katy's house was new -- new and huge, even though she was an only child. So new, in fact, that the sod lay in rolls next to the house, all over the expansive property, yet to be unfurled. "You'll all have to come back for a sod-rolling party," Katy's mother joked as she greeted us. Her presence at the door was our first clue that this was to be a children's sort of party.
The dining room was decorated with streamers and noisemakers and there were party hats and little crepe-paper cups filled with candy. We stood silently in the entryway: in my imagination I see us in two straight lines, like the girls in Madeline, except in this case the smallest one was Jen. For the most part we were all wispy and small, except for Lorna. Lorna (old money; highest caste) was what they used to call back then an "early bloomer." She was thirteen, but looked more like seventeen: tall, blonde and developed.
Lorna led the way and took a seat at the table, and it was our cue that we were all going to pretend this was normal: a child's party for a group of children who did not consider themselves children anymore. And since we were playing make-believe, we left the caste system outside by the rolls of sod and simply sat wherever we found an empty chair, with no thought to who belonged next to whom in the grand hierarchy.
It was a pizza party, and I remember Katy's dad carrying in the pizzas. As you know I've always had an old dad, but Katy's dad was young even compared to those of the rest of my classmates. He was young enough that we could see he was attractive as opposed to being just old, yuck! Someone's dad! Mr. Cooper was cheerful, even sanguine, able to joke around with us a bit without making his daughter die of embarrassment.
Since we'd made the unspoken agreement to be children at this party, we behaved like children. We got loud. There wasn't exactly a food fight, but at some point Karen Baumgarten reached into her crepe paper cup, pulled out a jelly bean and threw it at another girl. Pretty soon jelly beans were flying everywhere. Karen took a streamer from the chandelier and began prancing around the table, waving the streamer like a rhythmic gymnast.
Suddenly the swinging door between the kitchen and dining room opened and out came Mr. Cooper, looking like an entirely different person than the man who'd brought in the pizzas not a half hour earlier. His face was red, his plaid shirt untucked, and he yelled, "Just what in the Hell do you little bitches think you're doing?"
He yelled for what felt like a very long time, the gist of his argument being that fancy-pants girls like us that went to such a ritzy school should have better manners -- or maybe, he spat, maybe we did behave that way at home and just had a full staff of servants (ayas?) who picked up after us.
We were dead quiet. I looked at Katy and her eyes were squeezed shut, her face red, her hands clasped firmly on the table in front of her. Most of us had never seen a person leave the room with one personality and then re-emerge with another, but it was clear from Katy's face that this was something she had experienced before. Perhaps it had even been something she'd worried about in advance. Please don't let Dad do that thing that he does.
Lorna was the first to speak. "We all apologize, Mr. Cooper. We were having such a good time that things got out of hand and we forgot ourselves." We forgot ourselves? I remember thinking. Who says things like that?
Lorna said things like that. I remembered an incident that had happened a year earlier, in our Ancient Civilizations class. Mrs. P. had called on Lorna, who had been clearly staring into space. Lorna paused, then said, "I'm very sorry, Mrs. P., but I wasn't paying attention. Could you please repeat the question?" I think everyone in the room gasped. None of us had ever tried this gambit -- honesty -- and Mrs. P. was very impressed. She made a shining example of Lorna, praising her for being frank and mature.
Mr. Cooper was immediately disarmed. His face returned to its normal color and he was once again the man who brought in the pizzas. We all sighed and mumbled sorry. Mr. Cooper looked at Lorna for one, two, three...eleven seconds, during which she calmly picked up a slice of her pizza and resumed eating, all the while her gaze meeting his. Then she slowly lowered her focus to the slice of pizza in her hand, and Mr. Cooper left the room.
Katy was trembling and continued to do so long after the cake was cut, but somehow, we all rallied. I don't remember who broke the ice and got the conversation going again. Odds are it was Lorna.
After cake and presents, we all went into the emptied living room with our sleeping bags. We played Ha Ha, tentatively at first but then with abandon because Mrs. Cooper came in and told us, conspiratorially, that Mr. Cooper had retired for the night and could not hear us from their bedroom. We told ghost stories. We had chicken fights. We played "Light as a feather and stiff as a board." At some point in the evening, Karen Baumgarten reached menarche. Katy summoned Mrs. Cooper who handled the matter so smoothly that Karen opted not to call her own mother and tell her. It was a big night.
As often happens at sleep-over parties, the Early Bloomer was the first to fall asleep. We lost Lorna somewhere between the chicken fights (I know she was awake then, because I was the one on her shoulders) and "Light as a Feather." There was a great deal of discussion on what should be done to poor, unconscious Lorna, since it went without saying that taking advantage of the first to fall asleep was a cultural imperative. No one had thought in advance to bring shaving cream and drawing a moustache on her with an El Marko seemed cruelly permanent, so we got straws from the kitchen and pelted her with spitballs. After about thirty seconds she sat upright in her sleeping bag and said, eyes still closed, "That hurts my feelings very much!" We left her alone after that. Even in sleep, Lorna had the ability to humble us with her poise.
The next morning, Mr. Cooper was to drive us all home. Thankfully he was the Mr. Cooper with the pizzas, and not the one we'd seen briefly during the jelly bean fight. As we all piled into the Town and Country station wagon, Mrs. Cooper said her good-byes and then made a very odd demand: "Now girls, make sure each of you gives Mr. Cooper a kiss when he drops you off."
I didn't understand why she wanted us to do this. Was it so we'd forget he yelled at us and remember him instead as...friendly? I was only twelve, but I was old enough to understand that this was not the normal price of a ride home.
I remember climbing into the way, way back seat -- as far from Mr. Cooper as possible. Like I said he was being nice, but I wasn't about to take any chances.
Mr. Cooper asked Lorna, "You live the closest. Would you like to be dropped off first or last?" First, I thought, trying to communicate with her telepathically, but she said, looking right at him, "Last."
"Then you may as well sit in the front seat next to me," he said, relegating his own daughter to the second row.
Why would she choose last? These were in the years before children were empowered and knew terms like "just say no." It did not occur to me -- as I'm sure it didn't to any of the other girls -- that I had the right to decline the kiss. But Lorna had been given a choice, and in that situation it would have been fully permissable for her to say first. I did not understand it. It did not make sense. And like most things that did not make sense to me as a child, I put it out of my head. I did not think about it until I had thirteen-year-old daughters of my own. A girl -- a child --could get turned around by her own power. And then, in exercising that power, surrender it entirely.
The only mercy I saw in this car ride was that living as far south as I did, I was the third girl dropped off and the station wagon was still full of witnesses. The kiss was on the cheek was perfunctory. I had to stand on tip-toe and Mr. Cooper had to bend way over. It was clear mine was not the kiss he was looking forward to, but that was fine with me. I had a brother not much younger than Mr. Cooper, and I just pretended it was him.
I remember ringing the doorbell when I got home. Though both my parents worked, there was always someone home to let me in. We lived in the city, which meant it wasn't wise to leave the door unlocked. And yet somehow, I never had my own key as a child. It was a point of honor for my parents: no matter how much schedule juggling took place, I never came home to an empty house. It had never come to that.
My mom asked me how the party went, and I said, "Karen Baumgarten got her period." I don't remember what Mom replied.
I remember going into the sun parlor and throwing myself on the old red couch to do the one thing I hadn't done at the party: sleep. I felt glad I lived on the East Side, on a city block with all the houses right next to each other and sidewalks and straight driveways and a lawn small enough that the sod could all be rolled out by one person, as it almost certainly had been, close to a hundred years ago when our house was built.
I remember I felt glad to be twelve.